Butter Chicken with Fenugreek & Burnt-Butter Drizzle
Delhi winter comfort — tandoori char meets cream, nothing gets buttered up here
This isn't your butter chicken from a tin — it's what you eat in a Delhi kitchen when the fog rolls in and someone's actually bothered to char the bird properly first. The fenugreek (methi) is winter-fresh here, and the cream cuts the cold air like a proper coat. I've added burnt butter because restraint is for people without taste buds.
How to Cook It
- 01
Char the chicken
Pat thighs dry. Heat a cast-iron skillet or tawa until smoking. Season chicken generously, skin-side down first — don't move it, let it catch colour for 6–7 minutes. Flip, char the other side 4–5 minutes. You want blackened edges and rendered skin. Set aside on a warm plate.
~15 min - 02
Build the base
In a heavy pan, melt 40g butter over medium heat. Add ginger-garlic paste, cook 2 minutes until fragrant — the paste should darken slightly. Add crushed tomatoes and kasuri methi. Simmer 8–10 minutes, stirring often. The sauce should reduce by a third and smell sweet and deep.
~12 min - 03
Cream & fenugreek fold
Lower heat. Stir in cream slowly — no curdling. Add half the fresh methi leaves, torn. Return charred chicken to the pan, nestling it into sauce. Season to taste. Simmer gently for 12–15 minutes until chicken is cooked through and sauce clings to it.
~15 min - 04
Burn the butter (the good bit)
In a small pan, melt remaining 80g butter over medium-high heat. Watch it — once it foams and the milk solids turn hazelnut-brown (about 4–5 minutes), pour it straight into a bowl. It should smell nutty and bitter-sweet, almost smoky.
~6 min - 05
Plate & drizzle
Transfer chicken and sauce to a warm bowl or plates. Scatter remaining fresh methi on top. Drizzle the burnt butter — every drop — over everything. Taste, adjust salt. That burnt butter is your signature here; don't be shy.
~5 min
“Serve in a shallow bowl or on a plate wide enough for sauce to pool. The chicken sits in the middle, creamy sauce around it, charred skin still visible. Fresh methi scattered raw on top adds colour and peppery bite. The burnt-butter drizzle goes on last, warm, so it catches the light. Serve with rice or naan — something to soak up every drop of sauce. This isn't fancy; it's honest.”
First spoonful: creamy, warm tomato hits you, then fenugreek's peppery sweetness. The chicken skin cracks between your teeth, charred and crisp. Mid-bite, the burnt butter arrives — nutty, almost smoky, cutting through richness. Finish is long, warm, a whisper of methi and blackened edges. Proper comfort that doesn't apologise.
Swap chicken thighs for 800g cauliflower florets or 600g firm tofu (pressed and cubed) — char them the same way in the skillet until deeply browned. Use vegan butter (80g coconut oil or quality plant-based butter works) and replace heavy cream with 200ml coconut cream or cashew cream (soak 100g raw cashews 30 minutes, blend with 200ml hot water and salt). The rest stays the same: ginger-garlic, tomatoes, fresh and dried methi, burnt-butter drizzle. Tofu absorbs the sauce beautifully; cauliflower gives you texture and char. The burnt butter (vegan) still carries the whole dish.
Acidity cuts cream, mineral backbone handles fenugreek's pepperiness without competing
Cold, clean, refreshes between bites of rich sauce and charred bird
Chai's warmth mirrors the dish; lime soda cuts through cream like a knife
- ·Don't skip the char — it's where all the flavour lives. A proper blackened edge makes the cream sing.
- ·Burnt butter is not a mistake. Watch it carefully; once it turns amber-brown and smells nutty, pour it off. The milk solids sink; drizzle the golden liquid.
- ·Fresh methi wilts in an hour, so buy it the day you cook. If you can't find it, dried kasuri methi alone is honest, but fresh makes the dish.
Show us yours.
Cooked this dish? Snap a photo, share it here. No filter, no fuss — the good, the wonky, the accidentally set-fire-to.
Sign in to share your photo of this dish.
No one's cooked this yet — be the first.